5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 1
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 2
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 3
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 4
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 5
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 6
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 7
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 8
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 9
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 10
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 11
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 12
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 13
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 14
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 15
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 16
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 17
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 18
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 19
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 20
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 21
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 22
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 23
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 24
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 25
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 26
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 27
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 28
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 29
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 30
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 31
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 32
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 33
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 34
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 35
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 36
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 37
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 38
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 39
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 40
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 41
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 42
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 43
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 44
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 45
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 46
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 47
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 48
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 49
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 50
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 51
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 52
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 53
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 54
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 55
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 56
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546 - View 57

5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

List Price: $1,699,000On Market FlagOn market
Aug 15, 20253,214 sqft5 beds4 baths
Listed by: Leslie Foster
License #: 01804083
Phone #: 510-397-0696
eXp Realty of California
Source:
CRMLS Logo
MLS #: 41108283

Property Description

Welcome to 5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley. A stunning 5-bed, 4-bath custom-built home offering 3,214 sq.ft. of thoughtfully designed living space. Tucked away on a private flag lot, this residence combines elegance, comfort, & convenience in one perfect package. Step inside to soaring ceilings, a formal living & dining area, ideal for entertaining. The expansive chef’s kitchen features ample counter space, premium appliances, and an open layout that flows seamlessly into the spacious family room. A full bedroom and bathroom on the main level provide the perfect setup for guests or multi-generational living. Upstairs, you’ll find four additional bedrooms, including two with ensuite baths. The luxurious primary suite boasts breathtaking views, a spa-inspired bathroom, & a generous walk-in closet. A versatile flex space upstairs offers endless possibilities—home office, study area, or media lounge. Fresh interior paint and beautiful hardwood floors throughout elevate the home’s timeless style. Enjoy a large 2 car garage & easy access to the outdoors—walk to Proctor Elementary, explore Ten Hills Trail to Lake Chabot, or play a round at Redwood Canyon Golf Course. Conveniently located near downtown, freeways, and BART, this home is perfectly positioned for both relaxation & commuting.
Assignment
Get a detailed valuation report, schedule a tour or make an offer!
Kevin Kretzmer
Kevin Kretzmer

Role: TurboHome Head Agent

Experience: 10 years

No. of Transactions: 227

“I specialize in helping clients find their dream home or next investment in California, focusing on residential and multi-family properties. My client-first approach, clear communication, and attention to detail ensure that everyone I work with receives exceptional service.”

TurboHome Fair Market Estimate

TurboHome

TurboHome Savings

$30,381

TurboHome Estimated Value

$1,862,200

$579 sqft

High Valuation
$1,955,310
$608/sqft
Normal Valuation
$1,862,200
$579/sqft
Low Valuation
$1,769,090
$550/sqft

3rd Party Estimates

Source$/sqftValuation
HouseCanary$579/sqft$1,862,200

Neighborhood: PROCTOR

Loading map...

Comparative Value

$1.68M

$1.77M

$2.40M

3940 Alexia Pl, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale Price: $1,675,000

Selected Comparable

5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

List Price: $1,699,000

Subject Property

4635 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale Price: $1,700,000

Selected Comparable

4179 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale Price: $1,700,000

Selected Comparable

17811 Center St, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale Price: $1,770,000

Selected Comparable

5272 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale Price: $2,400,000

Selected Comparable

Neighborhood Comps

Subject Property

SUBJECT
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

List: $1,699,000

Listed: 8/15/2025

Area:3,214 sqft
Price/sqft:$529
Beds:5
Baths:4
Year Built:
Lot Size:7,113

Comparable Properties

COMPARABLE
Choose comps
3940 Alexia Pl, Castro Valley, CA 94546

3940 Alexia Pl, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale: $1,675,000

7/11/20250.89 mi

Area:3,136 sqft
Price/sqft:$534
Beds:5
Baths:4
Year Built:
Weight:23.9%
17811 Center St, Castro Valley, CA 94546

17811 Center St, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale: $1,770,000

1/27/20250.62 mi

Area:3,350 sqft
Price/sqft:$528
Beds:5
Baths:3
Year Built:
Weight:19.7%
4635 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

4635 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale: $1,700,000

3/12/20250.63 mi

Area:3,981 sqft
Price/sqft:$427
Beds:5
Baths:4
Year Built:
Weight:19.5%
4179 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

4179 Seven Hills Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale: $1,700,000

6/18/20250.72 mi

Area:2,758 sqft
Price/sqft:$616
Beds:5
Baths:5
Year Built:
Weight:19.2%
5272 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

5272 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Sale: $2,400,000

12/6/20240.11 mi

Area:3,711 sqft
Price/sqft:$647
Beds:4
Baths:4
Year Built:
Weight:17.6%

How it Works

1

Meet your local TurboHome agent

We match you with an in-house licensed real estate agent who knows your market
2

We support your home-buying journey

Everything you'd expect your agent to do: touring, analysis, coaching, offers, negotiations, and closing
3

You get big savings

You split the commission with your agent 50/50, saving you thousands compared to a traditional agent
Two iPhones. One with a TurboHome screen that contains a profile photo and 'Meet Kevin' heading. The other with a TurboHome IQ screen with an example Disclosure Summary.
The Mercury News
CBS News
Business Insider
Orange County Register
Silicon Valley
East Bay Times