2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 1
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 2
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 3
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 4
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 5
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 6
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 7
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 8
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 9
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 10
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 11
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 12
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 13
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 14
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 15
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 16
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 17
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 18
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 19
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 20
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 21
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 22
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 23
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 24
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 25
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 26
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 27
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 28
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 29
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 30
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 31
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 32
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 33
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 34
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 35
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 36
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 37
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 38
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 39
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 40
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 41
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 42
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 43
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 44
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 45
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 46
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 47
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 48
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 49
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 50
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 51
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 52
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 53
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 54
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 55
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 56
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 57
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 58
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 59
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 60
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 61
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 62
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 63
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 64
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 65
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 66
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 67
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 68
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 69
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 70
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 71
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 72
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 73
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 74
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 75
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 76
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 77
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 78
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 79
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 80
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 81
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 82
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 83
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 84
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 85
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 86
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125 - View 87

2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $3,050,000
May 7, 20252,110 sqft3 beds2 baths
Listed by: Linda Baker
License #: 01373033
Phone #: 408-712-3432
Milestone Realty
Source:
CRMLS Logo
MLS #: ML82005743

Property Description

First time on the market in over 60 years, this cherished home is located on one of the most desirable streets within The Gates, a neighborhood celebrated for its large lots, community spirit, and walkable access to top-rated public schools. Set on an expansive 1/4+ acre lot, this 1950s ranch-style home offers a unique blend of opportunity and legacy. The home is ideally set back from the street, creating a relaxed, welcoming curb appeal. A front courtyard with a built-in fireplace and Spanish-style tile invites evening gatherings, neighborly waves, and California outdoor living at its finest. Inside, the spacious layout features large picture windows, original hardwood floors (preserved beneath carpet), and a light-filled family room that opens directly to the backyard. The rear yard is a private retreat, complete with pool, spa, and mature landscaping, perfect for both quiet enjoyment and entertaining. Whether you choose to restore the existing charm or reimagine the property entirely, the possibilities are as expansive as the lot itself. With its unbeatable location, generous footprint, and rarely available setting, this is your chance to build or personalize your dream estate in one of Willow Glens most prestigious streets.
Assignment
Get a detailed valuation report, schedule a tour or make an offer!
Kevin Kretzmer
Kevin Kretzmer

Role: TurboHome Head Agent

Experience: 10 years

No. of Transactions: 227

“I specialize in helping clients find their dream home or next investment in California, focusing on residential and multi-family properties. My client-first approach, clear communication, and attention to detail ensure that everyone I work with receives exceptional service.”

TurboHome Fair Market Estimate

TurboHome

TurboHome Savings

$43,389

TurboHome Estimated Value

$2,771,300

$1,313 sqft

High Valuation
$2,909,865
$1379/sqft
Normal Valuation
$2,771,300
$1313/sqft
Low Valuation
$2,632,735
$1248/sqft

3rd Party Estimates

Source$/sqftValuation
HouseCanary$1313/sqft$2,771,300

Neighborhood: Willow Glen

Loading map...

Comparative Value

$1.96M

$2.15M

$2.52M

$2.65M

$3.05M

2980 Booksin Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $1,960,000

Selected Comparable

2562 Fairglen Dr, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $2,152,000

Selected Comparable

1141 Denise Way, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $2,170,000

Selected Comparable

1244 Husted Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $2,518,000

Selected Comparable

2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

List Price: $2,650,000

Subject Property

2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale Price: $3,050,000

Selected Comparable

Neighborhood Comps

Subject Property

SUBJECT
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

List: $2,650,000

Listed: 5/7/2025

Area:2,110 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,256
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Lot Size:12,610

Comparable Properties

COMPARABLE
Choose comps
2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

2557 Cottle Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale: $3,050,000

6/13/20250.00 mi

Area:2,110 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,445
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:24.6%
1141 Denise Way, San Jose, CA 95125

1141 Denise Way, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale: $2,170,000

4/21/20250.32 mi

Area:1,686 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,287
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:20.2%
1244 Husted Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

1244 Husted Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale: $2,518,000

11/20/20240.22 mi

Area:2,059 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,223
Beds:3
Baths:3
Year Built:
Weight:19.8%
2980 Booksin Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

2980 Booksin Ave, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale: $1,960,000

10/6/20240.61 mi

Area:1,845 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,062
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:19.5%
2562 Fairglen Dr, San Jose, CA 95125

2562 Fairglen Dr, San Jose, CA 95125

Sale: $2,152,000

3/21/20250.61 mi

Area:1,783 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,207
Beds:4
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:15.9%

How it Works

1

Meet your local TurboHome agent

We match you with an in-house licensed real estate agent who knows your market
2

We support your home-selling journey

Everything you'd expect your agent to do: pricing, listing, photos, staging, open houses, and negotiating
3

You get big savings

You split the commission with your agent 50/50, saving you thousands compared to a traditional agent
Two iPhones. One with a TurboHome screen that contains a profile photo and 'Meet Kevin' heading. The other with a TurboHome IQ screen with an example Disclosure Summary.
The Mercury News
CBS News
Business Insider
Orange County Register
Silicon Valley
East Bay Times