454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - View 1

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - View 2

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - View 3

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - Main View

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - Additional View 1

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060 - Additional View 2

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

List Price: $649,000

On market

May 29, 20251,936 sqft3 beds3 baths

Listed by: Bob Day

License #: 00851770

Phone #: 323-821-4820

Coldwell Banker Realty

Source:

MLS #: 25548187

Assignment

Get a detailed valuation report, schedule a tour or make an offer!

Kevin Kretzmer

Role: TurboHome Head Agent

Experience: 10 years

No. of Transactions: 227

“I specialize in helping clients find their dream home or next investment in California, focusing on residential and multi-family properties. My client-first approach, clear communication, and attention to detail ensure that everyone I work with receives exceptional service.”

DRE LICENSE #01997822

California Association of Realtors

TurboHome Fair Market Estimate

TurboHome

TurboHome Savings

$12,867

TurboHome Estimated Value

$678,900

$351 sqft

High Valuation

$712,845

$368/sqft

Normal Valuation

$678,900

$351/sqft

Low Valuation

$644,955

$333/sqft

3rd Party Estimates

Source	$/sqft	Valuation
HouseCanary	$351	$678,900

Assignment

Get a detailed valuation report, schedule a tour or make an offer!

Kevin Kretzmer

Role: TurboHome Head Agent

Experience: 10 years

No. of Transactions: 227

“I specialize in helping clients find their dream home or next investment in California, focusing on residential and multi-family properties. My client-first approach, clear communication, and attention to detail ensure that everyone I work with receives exceptional service.”

DRE LICENSE #01997822

California Association of Realtors

Neighborhood

Loading map...

Comparative Value

$649K

$676K

$687K

$715K

$769K

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

List Price: $649,000

Subject Property

501 Olinda Way, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale Price: $676,000

Selected Comparable

376 Fuerte Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale Price: $687,000

Selected Comparable

472 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale Price: $715,000

Selected Comparable

384 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale Price: $715,000

Selected Comparable

2133 Seville Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale Price: $769,000

Selected Comparable

Neighborhood Comps

Subject Property

SUBJECT

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

List: $649,000

Listed: 5/29/2025

Area:1,936 sqft

Price/sqft:$335

Beds:3

Baths:3

Year Built:—

Lot Size:6,000

Comparable Properties

COMPARABLE

Choose comps

472 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

472 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale: $715,000

4/25/2025 • 0.06 mi

Area:1,936 sqft

Price/sqft:$369

Beds:3

Baths:3

Year Built:—

Weight:22.1%

501 Olinda Way, Santa Paula, CA 93060

501 Olinda Way, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale: $676,000

1/30/2025 • 0.11 mi

Area:1,860 sqft

Price/sqft:$363

Beds:3

Baths:3

Year Built:—

Weight:20.6%

384 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

384 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale: $715,000

9/4/2024 • 0.10 mi

Area:1,860 sqft

Price/sqft:$384

Beds:3

Baths:3

Year Built:—

Weight:19.7%

2133 Seville Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

2133 Seville Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale: $769,000

3/11/2025 • 0.13 mi

Area:1,950 sqft

Price/sqft:$394

Beds:3

Baths:2

Year Built:—

Weight:19.0%

376 Fuerte Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

376 Fuerte Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060

Sale: $687,000

5/14/2025 • 0.15 mi

Area:1,954 sqft

Price/sqft:$352

Beds:4

Baths:3

Year Built:—

Weight:18.5%

Subject Property

SUBJECT

Image	Address	List Price	sqft	Price/sqft	Lot Size	Distance	List Date	Beds	Baths	Year Built	Weight
	454 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$649,000	1,936	$335	6,000	—	5/29/2025	3	3	—	—

Comparable Properties

COMPARABLE

Choose comps

Image	Address	Sale Price	sqft	Price/sqft	Lot Size	Distance	Sale Date	Beds	Baths	Year Built	Weight
	472 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$715,000	1,936	$369	6,000	0.06 mi	4/25/2025	3	3	—	22.1%
	501 Olinda Way, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$676,000	1,860	$363	6,000	0.11 mi	1/30/2025	3	3	—	20.6%
	384 Tibbetts St, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$715,000	1,860	$384	3,253	0.10 mi	9/4/2024	3	3	—	19.7%
	2133 Seville Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$769,000	1,950	$394	4,791	0.13 mi	3/11/2025	3	2	—	19.0%
	376 Fuerte Dr, Santa Paula, CA 93060	$687,000	1,954	$352	3,455	0.15 mi	5/14/2025	4	3	—	18.5%

Nearby Listings

2 similar properties within 5 miles

Property placeholder

420 Celebration Ln, Santa Paula, CA 93060

List Price: $760,000

420 Celebration Ln, Santa Paula, CA 93060

3 bd 3 ba 2,226 sqft

TurboHome Est. Value:

$734,000

Property placeholder

752 Fillmore St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

List Price: $754,900

752 Fillmore St, Santa Paula, CA 93060

4 bd 2 ba 1,369 sqft

TurboHome Est. Value:

$734,000

How it Works

1

Meet your local TurboHome agent

We match you with an in-house licensed real estate agent who knows your market

2

We support your homebuying journey

Everything you'd expect your agent to do: touring, analysis, coaching, offers, negotiations, and closing

3

You get big savings

Choose how you want to receive your TurboHome savings — Boost your offer, cash at closing, or lower mortgage rate