505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 1
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 2
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 3
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 4
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 5
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 6
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 7
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 8
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 9
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 10
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 11
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 12
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 13
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 14
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 15
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 16
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 17
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 18
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 19
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 20
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 21
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 22
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 23
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 24
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 25
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 26
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 27
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 28
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 29
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 30
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 31
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 32
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 33
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 34
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 35
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 36
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 37
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 38
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 39
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 40
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 41
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 42
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 43
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 44
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 45
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 46
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 47
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 48
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 49
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 50
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 51
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 52
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 53
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 54
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 55
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 56
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062 - View 57

505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

Sale Price: $2,400,000
Jun 30, 20251,881 sqft3 beds2 baths
Listed by: Julie Hansmann
License #: 00667831
Phone #: 831-334-7286
David Lyng Real Estate
Source:
CRMLS Logo
MLS #: ML82012867

Property Description

Beautiful, lovingly restored Victorian in the Heart of Seabright! This spacious home features large rooms, high ceilings, skylights and an abundance of natural light. The sunny kitchen offers plenty of workspace, dining area, and a new ILVE Majestic induction stove. Enjoy the charming front sunroom-perfect for relaxing and watching the neighbors and nature go by. Walk to Seabright Beach, the Yacht Harbor, Arana Gulch, and favorite local restaurants, like La Posta, and Seabright Social or Lillians. You can bike to Mid-Town, Capitola or the Boardwalk and the Westside in minutes. Modern upgrades include a new foundation, roof, furnace, sewer lateral, electrical service, fully owned solar system, and EV charger. Set on a rare quarter acre-double lot, the property is a true outdoor oasis with mature fruit trees. There are many raised vegetable beds, several vibrant flower gardens and a large garden shed. Entertain or unwind in the outdoor dining area, by the fire pit, or in the newer hot tub and sauna. Bonus features include a one-of-a-kind wine barrel guest house or office, and a full outdoor bathroom with shower. Large workshop and storage shed can accommodate all your hobbies. A perfect blend of vintage charm and modern living in one of Santa Cruz's most beloved neighborhoods!
Assignment
Get a detailed valuation report, schedule a tour or make an offer!
Kevin Kretzmer
Kevin Kretzmer

Role: TurboHome Head Agent

Experience: 10 years

No. of Transactions: 227

“I specialize in helping clients find their dream home or next investment in California, focusing on residential and multi-family properties. My client-first approach, clear communication, and attention to detail ensure that everyone I work with receives exceptional service.”

TurboHome Fair Market Estimate

TurboHome

TurboHome Savings

$29,457

TurboHome Estimated Value

$2,031,400

$1,080 sqft

High Valuation
$2,132,970
$1134/sqft
Normal Valuation
$2,031,400
$1080/sqft
Low Valuation
$1,929,830
$1026/sqft

3rd Party Estimates

Source$/sqftValuation
HouseCanary$1080/sqft$2,031,400

Neighborhood

Loading map...

Comparative Value

$1.81M

$2.10M

$2.40M

712 California St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

Sale Price: $1,810,000

Selected Comparable

505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

List Price: $2,099,000

Subject Property

505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

Sale Price: $2,400,000

Selected Comparable

Neighborhood Comps

Subject Property

SUBJECT
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

List: $2,099,000

Listed: 6/30/2025

Area:1,881 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,116
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Lot Size:10,893

Comparable Properties

COMPARABLE
Choose comps
505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

505 Cayuga St, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

Sale: $2,400,000

7/28/20250.00 mi

Area:1,881 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,276
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:53.5%
712 California St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

712 California St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

Sale: $1,810,000

8/11/20251.32 mi

Area:1,759 sqft
Price/sqft:$1,029
Beds:3
Baths:2
Year Built:
Weight:46.5%

How it Works

1

Meet your local TurboHome agent

We match you with an in-house licensed real estate agent who knows your market
2

We support your home-selling journey

Everything you'd expect your agent to do: pricing, listing, photos, staging, open houses, and negotiating
3

You get big savings

You split the commission with your agent 50/50, saving you thousands compared to a traditional agent
Two iPhones. One with a TurboHome screen that contains a profile photo and 'Meet Kevin' heading. The other with a TurboHome IQ screen with an example Disclosure Summary.
The Mercury News
CBS News
Business Insider
Orange County Register
Silicon Valley
East Bay Times