Glossary

Right of First Refusal

Understanding the Right of First Refusal

Plain-English Definition

The right of first refusal (ROFR) is a contractual promise giving one party the option to buy a property before the owner can sell to someone else. When the owner accepts a third-party offer, they must first present that offer to the ROFR holder, who can match it or waive the right.

Common Contexts

ROFR clauses are common in:

How the Right of First Refusal Works

Triggering Events and Third-Party Offers

A ROFR is “triggered” when the property owner receives a bona fide third-party offer. That offer’s key terms—price, contingencies, closing date—set the benchmark the ROFR holder must meet.

Notice Requirements and Response Deadlines

The owner must notify the ROFR holder in writing, typically by certified mail, email or another specified method. The agreement defines the response window—often 5–30 days—to exercise or waive the right.

Exercising, Waiving or Declining the Right

If the holder exercises, they sign a purchase contract on the same terms as the third-party offer. If they waive or miss the deadline, the owner is free to sell to the third party under those original terms.

Right of First Refusal vs. Other Preemptive Rights

First Offer (First Look) vs. First Refusal

With a first offer right, the holder sees or negotiates a deal before the owner markets broadly—but isn’t guaranteed matching terms. A ROFR waits for a fully negotiated third-party offer.

Right of First Negotiation

A right of first negotiation obligates the owner to negotiate exclusively with the holder before talking to outsiders. If talks fail, the owner can then solicit other bids.

Preemption Rights in HOA and Co-op Documents

Homeowners associations and co-op boards often include preemption or ROFR clauses to control ownership changes and maintain community standards.

Pros and Cons for Holders and Grantors

Benefits to Buyers, Lessees and Investors

Drawbacks: Timing Risks, Market Impact, Hidden Costs

Strategic Uses for Sellers and Landlords

Drafting and Negotiating a Strong Clause

Defining Clear Timeframes and Notice Methods

Specify exact deadlines (e.g., “10 business days”) and approved delivery methods (email with read receipt, certified mail) to avoid disputes.

Price-Matching Language and Valuation Mechanisms

Require the holder to match the full third-party terms or use an independent appraisal process if the holder disputes the offer’s validity.

Assignability, Transfer Restrictions and Carve-Outs

Clarify whether the ROFR can be assigned, whether affiliates qualify, and carve-outs for transfers to heirs or corporate subsidiaries.

Legal and Financial Pitfalls to Avoid

Enforceability Under State and Local Law

Some jurisdictions view ROFRs as restraints on alienation and may demand a legitimate business purpose. Confirm local statutes and case law.

Penalties for Notice or Procedural Missteps

Failure to comply with notice or deadline rules can waive the ROFR or expose the owner to damages or specific performance claims.

Unexpected Fees, Closing Costs and Obligations

Spell out which party pays appraisal, attorney or transfer fees. Hidden costs can erode the benefit of matching an offer.

Common Questions (FAQs)

Can I Assign or Transfer My Right of First Refusal?

Only if the clause expressly permits assignment. Otherwise the right typically stays personal to the original holder.

What If the Seller Misses the Notice Deadline?

The holder may treat the right as waived or seek to enforce it in court, depending on the agreement’s remedies clause.

How Are Conflicts Handled When Multiple Holders Exist?

Agreements often rank holders (first, second, third) or allocate proportional interests to resolve competing claims.

Must I Match Exactly the Third-Party Offer?

Yes—unless the ROFR clause allows variations or requires an appraisal-based valuation instead of strict matching.

Real World Application

Fictional Scenario: Co-op Shareholder Wants to Buy Neighbor’s Unit

• The neighbor submits a $500,000 offer to the board, triggering the shareholder’s ROFR.
• The board mails a notice by certified mail; the shareholder has 15 days to respond.
• The shareholder elects to match the offer, signs the contract and closes as buyer—blocking the external sale.

Key Takeaways from the Example

Key Takeaways and Next Steps

Quick Definition Recap

A ROFR gives a party the right to match a third-party property offer before the owner can sell to anyone else.

Checklist for Negotiating or Exercising Your Right

When to Consult a Real Estate Attorney or Advisor

Engage professional counsel when drafting or enforcing a ROFR to navigate local laws, avoid forfeiture of rights and ensure smooth closings.

Michael McCleskey